A D.O.C. original · for fans

Kings of Clean vs. Queens of Mean Clean comedy takes on the roast.

Clean comedy vs. roast comedy: two ways to kill a room. Only one of them is allowed at your cousin's wedding.

Funny is funny. This page just sorts it into two piles.

The opening argument

Some comics can make a theater full of strangers laugh without a word you couldn't say in church.Others find the one thing your grandmother would never say out loud, say it twice, and get her laughing anyway.

This page is about those two kinds of comic: the ones who keep it clean, and the ones who go straight for the throat.

Yes, the title hands the clean crown to the kings and the mean one to the queens. That's alliteration, not a law. Plenty of women work spotless and plenty of men live for the roast, and they get crowns of their own further down.

Same job either way. Get the laugh.

The short version

Clean comedy and roast comedy, plainly

Clean comedy is stand-up you could do at a church supper or on network TV: no swearing and nothing explicit. It isn't kids' stuff. A clean comic can talk about marriage or getting old like anybody else; the words just stay clean. If you write your own act and want it that way, here is how to write a clean comedy set.

Roast comedy is the insult turned into a show. At a roast, comics take turns tearing into a guest of honor who agreed to sit there and take it, and the guest gets the last word. Insult comics bring the same nerve to a club and work over the front row.

The two meet more often than you'd think. A roast joke can be spotless, and a clean comic can be brutal. Most of the time the difference is the target: clean comics mostly aim at themselves and everyday life, and roast comics aim at the person in the chair. For a comic deciding where their own act sits, there's clean vs. dirty comedy.

The case for clean

Kings of Clean

No swearing. No problem.

Jim Gaffigan got a whole bit out of Hot Pockets. Brian Regan can have a sold-out theater gasping over a box of Pop-Tarts. Nate Bargatze tells you about his dad in a voice so calm you'd think he was reading you to sleep, and then you can't breathe.

Jerry Seinfeld has spent fifty years asking about things nobody else thought were worth a question. People still pay to hear the answers.

Clean comedy gets called safe. Try it sometime. Stand in front of two thousand people with nothing to shock them with and nothing to bleep. Every laugh has to come from the writing.

Clean doesn't make a joke good, either. A clean joke can die on stage as hard as any other. Leaving the swearing out isn't the skill. Being this funny without it is.

Nothing's missing. That's the point.

In this corner: Brian Regan, Nate Bargatze, Jim Gaffigan, Jerry Seinfeld

The case for mean

Queens of Mean

They said what you were thinking. Then they kept going.

Joan Rivers opened with "Can we talk?" and then talked about everything you'd been raised not to. Lisa Lampanelli was a fixture on the celebrity roast stage for years. Nikki Glaser walked into the roast of Tom Brady and walked out as the story everyone was talking about the next morning.

These comics aren't trying to make you comfortable. Half the time, the squirm is the joke.

Mean is harder than it looks. Anyone can be rude. A great roast comic finds the one true thing about you, makes it funnier than you knew it could be, and somehow you're the one laughing loudest.

An insult with no joke in it is just an insult. The great ones never forget that, and the crowd always knows.

Rude is easy. Rude and funny takes years.

In this corner: Joan Rivers, Lisa Lampanelli, Nikki Glaser

The argument nobody wins

So who's funnier? Wrong question.

Depends who's holding the mic.

Give Brian Regan five minutes on a trip to the emergency room and you'll miss a breath or two. Give Nikki Glaser five minutes with a celebrity who agreed to be roasted, and somebody should check on the celebrity.

Some of the meanest things ever said on a stage didn't have a single swear in them. Some of the filthiest sets ever recorded don't have a cruel bone in their body.

Maybe you laugh because you recognize yourself. Maybe because it's about somebody else for a change. And sometimes you laugh because you know you shouldn't, which is its own kind of fun.

There's room on the bill for all of it.

The obvious objection

What about the other two?

Fair. The title rhymes better than it reasons. Leanne Morgan can fill a theater without a single bleep, and Don Rickles spent more than sixty years insulting the people who paid to see him.

So the crowns flip too.

Your turn

You be the judge.

This one isn't about who's funniest. Some great comics just aren't your thing, and that's fine. Tell us which kind of funny you'd rather spend a night with, then who does it best.

1 Which style is yours?

Pick a side.

One vote. Change it whenever you like. We don't need your name.

Last word

There are no bad words. Just bad jokes.

Fine, a few bad words. Don't try them out at your grandmother's birthday.

But nobody ever walked out of a great set counting the swears. They walk out quoting it to whoever drove.

Some comics do it with a whisper. Some bring a flamethrower. Go see both.

The crown goes to the laugh.

Keep following the funny

Updated