A stand-up set critique from the tape you already have.
The one person who cannot hear a stand-up set properly is the person who was on stage doing it. Paste
the transcript of a tape and get back what the room heard and you did not —
your pace, the phrase you lean on, the swearing under your breath, where you stopped
talking — and the ums, where your captions kept them. It runs on this device. Nothing is
uploaded.
A set critique starts with the words you actually said.
YouTube writes a
transcript for every video it captions, unlisted ones included. Three steps, on a computer.
01
Open your set on YouTube
Under the video, expand the description and press "Show transcript", or find it in the ⋯ menu.
No transcript? The video has no captions yet: YouTube writes them a while
after upload, and never if they are switched off. Upload it unlisted and come back.
02
Copy the whole panel
Select from the first line to the last and copy, timestamps and all.
Keep the times on: your pace and your silences are measured from them.
03
Paste it below
Paste it into the box under Run a stand-up set critique and press Read it.
No YouTube? A caption file from your editor (.srt or .vtt) works too. Plain
text with no times gives you the counts, just not the pace or the silences.
Run a stand-up set critique
Six questions the read-out answers from your tape, each a card of its own once you press Read it:
1
Am I rushing?
Your words a minute, minute by minute, and whether you talk the first ninety seconds faster than the rest.
2
What am I leaning on?
Every um and uh with its count, the worst offender first, and the maybe-filler only you can judge.
3
What am I saying without knowing it?
Any three- or four-word phrase you said three times or more: a tic, or a callback doing its job.
4
Does a clean version exist?
Clean, some language or blue, with each word and the stretch of the set it falls in.
5
Where are the laughs?
The laughs your captions mark, or your longest silences in their place, each with the line before it.
6
What is this set about?
The words it keeps coming back to. Set them against what you thought it was about.
One tape tells you about one night. Keep the numbers from each set critique and
see whether they move — fewer ums a minute is a thing you can actually watch happen.
Nothing kept yet. Read a set and keep the result to
see whether the numbers move from one tape to the next.
How to critique your own stand-up set
The read-out does the counting. The rest is yours, and it takes about as long as the set
did. Do it the night of the set or the next morning, while you still remember the room.
1
Watch it once as the audience
Play the whole tape without stopping and without notes. You are checking one thing: would you have laughed,
and where did you stop paying attention? The spot where you drift is where the room drifted too.
Do this: note the minute you drifted.
2
Mark every laugh
Note the time of each laugh, big or small, then look at the gaps. A long stretch with no laugh is a setup
running long or a bit that hasn't found its punch yet. A laugh two words early has told you where the
punchline really is.
Do this: circle the longest gap between laughs.
3
Cut the dead stretch, then tighten
Fix the longest gap first, before you polish anything that already works. Cut the words the laugh doesn't
need, move the surprise to the last word, and try a tag after a joke that already lands.
Your pace, your filler, the phrase you lean on and the pauses are the habits you can't hear yourself.
Comedic timing covers the pauses, and
writing a clean set the swearing, if a booker asks for clean.
Do this: pick one habit for the next set, not all four.
5
Get one note from a comic you trust
A comic watching cold sees what you can't: the face you make before a punchline, the bit everyone else at the
mic is also doing.
Do this: ask for one note, not a review.
6
Log it and go up again
A critique is only useful if the next set is different. Stage Time's log
keeps which bits worked and builds your tight five from them, and how to get stage
time finds the next mic.
Do this: write down the one change and try it at the next mic.
Full specials, read the same way
These are full specials on YouTube, each run through the
read above exactly as a pasted tape is — the same counts and the same rules — so a finished hour sits
beside your own five minutes as a yardstick. A word cloud, the topics and a plain description of the
style come with each. As of 1 October 2026.
Side by side press a column to sort it — a higher number is a different style, not a better one
On the tape: the captions mark few or no laughs, so the silences stand in for them. The longest silence has applause marked in it.
Filler sounds: “ah” ×5, “uh” ×3.
How it reads, and the 40 words it says most
Some language0.2 swear words a minute — under the 1.5 a minute the read-out calls blue.
Unhurried pace94 words a minute across the set — room left for the laughs.
On the tape: the captions mark few or no laughs, so the silences stand in for them. The longest silence has applause marked in it.
Filler sounds: “uh” ×8, “ah” ×3.
How it reads, and the 40 words it says most
Some language0.5 swear words a minute — under the 1.5 a minute the read-out calls blue.
On the tape: the captions mark few or no laughs, so the silences stand in for them. The longest silence has applause marked in it.
Filler sounds: “um” ×1.
How it reads, and the 40 words it says most
Blue2.3 swear words a minute — the read-out calls 1.5 a minute and up blue.
The numbers are the read-out's own: words a minute over the whole set, laughs included;
filler a minute (um, uh, ah); swearing a minute, with a censored word on automatic captions counted;
the longest silence, the time after a line beyond what its words take to say.
Language is the read-out's band: clean when no swearing is on the captions, some language
under 1.5 words a minute, blue from 1.5 a minute.
Storyteller, setups that build, laughs close together come from the words between the laughs
the captions mark — 80 and more, 41 to 79, 40 and under — and only where the captions mark at least one
laugh a minute.
Brisk or unhurried pace: 170 words a minute and up, or 110 and under.
Act-outs: a voice set up and then played — “I'm like”, “she goes”, “he said” — two a minute
and more. Crowd work: someone in the room captioned speaking, or asked a question from the stage,
four times or more, or a stretch of the set spent with the audience.
Topics come from each chapter's title, or where it names none, from the words the chapter
uses most, weighted by the minutes it runs. The word cloud is the read-out's own count of the
words that carry a topic, with the comic's own name and any rough word left out.
Four compilation videos posted
alongside these hold 121 shorter sets from 100 comedians. The read here keeps to full
specials — one comic holding the room for the whole show — so the numbers compare like with like.
What this set critique does not do
It counts. It does not judge.
It cannot tell you whether anything was funny. A transcript holds the words, not the face, the timing or the
room, so where a question needs a person, the read-out says so instead of guessing.
For the funny: one note from a comic you trust.
Auto-captions are a rough draft
They drop ums, mishear names and almost never mark a laugh, so treat every count from them as a floor.